Today, Ontario Place for All released a comprehensive review of the financial viability of the proposed MegaSpa at Ontario Place. It concludes that the business case for the MegaSpa does not make sense, with the MegaSpa losing money for years while costing Ontario’s taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars in subsidies.
In a decision issued this week, the Honourable Justice Backhouse of the Ontario Divisional Court declined to grant a motion by Doug Ford’s government to quash Ontario Place for All’s application for judicial review, stating that:
“It cannot be said that OP4A’s concerns about governance in defiance of the environmental legislation are frivolous or unworthy of argument before a panel of the court, notwithstanding the passage of legislation which purports to retroactively sanitize the initial allegedly unlawful conduct. Where, as here, the questions are legal issues of first impression, in a context of significant public law interest and concern, the issue is more appropriately dealt with by a panel than by a single judge.”
PRESS RELEASE: Ontario Place for All Condemns Sudden Closure of West Island
Ontario Place for All takes legal action to stop the destruction of West Island
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
November 3rd, 2023
Ontario Place for All Welcomes Auditor General Audit of Ontario Place
Ontario Place for All welcomes the audit of Ontario Place and the Ontario Science Centre, and hopes the Auditor General will shine a light on the opaque and rushed processes that have led to the imminent destruction and 95-year giveaway of Ontario Place’s West Island for a MegaSpa, as well as the demolishing and diminishing of the Ontario Science Centre.
“At a time when emergency rooms are overwhelmed and there is a critical need for affordable housing, how do Ontario taxpayers and residents benefit from well over half a billion in corporate welfare going to support a private spa? I’m hopeful that the Auditor General can shine a light and help us understand what’s in this rushed and opaque deal for Ontarians,” says Norm Di Pasquale, Co-Chair of Ontario Place for All.
Last year, three community-based organizations (Ontario Place for All, Architectural Conservancy of Ontario, and Waterfront for All) with an interest in the future of Ontario Place filed a request with the Auditor General of Ontario to conduct a value for money audit and a compliance investigation in connection with the Therme spa proposal. The groups are looking for clarity as to how the public costs associated with the project line up with the potential benefits.
The Ontario Place development application filed with the City of Toronto confirms that massive subsidies have been extended to Therme, an Austrian spa group that has a conditional lease from the Province to turn the West Island of Ontario Place into a franchise of its European commercial spa operations.
In addition to an estimated $200 million in costs for servicing and site preparation, the Province has committed to providing an additional 2000+ parking spaces by building a 5-storey underground garage, which on the edge of Lake Ontario built on lakefill is actually an underwater garage. It has been suggested the cost for that could run to $450 million. Behind the scenes, an extraordinary amount of provincial staff time has gone into preparing the complex rezoning and development application on behalf of Therme. We suspect these estimated amounts will likely be higher, and hope that the Auditor General’s audit will confirm.
Since the request was made almost one year ago, Ontario Place for All has grown into a movement of Ontarians from all parts of the province and from all political backgrounds. With more than 35,000 letters sent to political decision makers about this important part of our future waterfront, the group is committed to protecting this amazing resource for our children, our children’s children, and beyond.
The groups have also asked for a compliance investigation looking at whether the province is also offside the Ontario Heritage Act, Environmental Protection Act, and the Environmental Assessment Act. The letter to the Auditor General can be found in the below link:
OP4A_WfA_ACO-AGO-audit-request_Final_Dec-5-22-.pdf (ontarioplaceforall.com)
– 30 –
Norm Di Pasquale – Co-Chair, Ontario Place for All
(647) 917-3198
Info@ontarioplaceforall.com
Ontario Place for All Condemns Province’s Plan to Cut a “Significant” Number of Trees at Ontario Place as Part of Province’s Flawed Development Resubmission
Ontario Place for All Invites Province to Consider A Better Idea for Ontario Place
PRESS RELEASE: Ontario Place for All Demands Accountability for Ontario Place June Consultation
Press Release: Ontario Place for All Condemns Lack of Transparency and Consultation Around the Science Centre Move to Ontario Place
Thanks to Terra Loire Gillespie for this guide – Taken from Terra’s Community Builder Toolbox, here: https://www.terraloiregillespie.com/community-builder-hub/community-building-tool-library How to Present an Effective Public Deputation
1. Introduction
What is a public deputation?
A deputation is a short statement made by an individual, group of people, or representative of a larger group in a formal procedure. In Toronto, public deputations are presented to the City’s committees, sub-committees, and community councils that report to City Council. These committees hold regular meetings to discuss relevant committee issues and welcome members of the public to make a deputation, or send in written comments on specific items. Committees then make recommendations to City Council for a final decision.
Public deputations are important in the decision-making process as they allow constituents to officially voice their views or concerns about a particular matter. Anyone can make a deputation – it is your right as a constituent to do so!
This guide provides five steps for presenting a public deputation:
1. Find out when and where to make your public deputation
2. Reserve a spot on the speaker list with the Committee Clerk
3. Prepare your public deputation
4. Present your public deputation
5. Follow up
1. Find out when and where to make your public deputation
1a. What committee should you present your deputation to?
The committee that you present your deputation to will depend on your issue or concern. With over 60 committees, sub-committees and community councils, finding an appropriate committee related to your issue can be confusing! There are several types of committees, each with their own area of consideration:
Community Councils:
Considers planning and neighbourhood matters for their part of the city.
Community councils report to City Council, but also have final decision-making power on certain items, such as sign and fence by-law exemptions.
Community councils: Etobicoke York, North York, Scarborough, Toronto and East York
Standing Policy Committees:
Distinct mandates in areas of public service delivery and corporate operations, including: monitoring current program delivery, service levels and emerging issues, and recommending policy and program changes.
Examples of standing policy committees: Community Development and Recreation, Licensing and Standards, and Parks and Environment
Executive Committee:
Monitors and makes recommendations on the priorities, plans, international and intergovernmental relations, and the financial integrity of the City, including financial planning and budgeting, council and its operations, and fiscal policy.
Makes recommendations or refers to another committee any matter not within their mandate or that relates to more than one standing committee.
Several committees report mainly to the Executive, including: Affordable Housing Committee, Budget Committee, and Employee and Labour Relations Committee
Other Committees of Council:
Members of Council also serve on these committees that report directly to Council, including: Civic Appointments Committee, Board of Health, and Audit Committee
To find out more information on each of Toronto’s committees, sub-committees, and community councils, visit the Toronto City Council and Committees website. On each committee’s website, you’ll find information on:
What issues the committee oversees
Upcoming and past scheduled meetings (with related meeting agendas, minutes, committee decisions, and background reports)
Committee members
Contact information for the Committee Clerk
If you cannot find an appropriate committee, you can always contact Toronto 311 for more information.
1b. When and where is the next committee meeting?
To find out about upcoming committee meetings, you can use the City of Toronto’s meeting schedule calendar. The calendar is updated in real time and lists committee meeting dates, times, locations, and meeting agendas. If you already know which committee you will deputing at, you can also find upcoming meeting details on their website.
2. Reserve a spot on the speaker list with the Committee Clerk
To make a public deputation, you must reserve a spot on the speaker list with the Committee Clerk (also called a Secretariat). Contact information for a Committee Clerk can be found on a committee’s website. You can sign up as soon as a meeting’s agenda is made public, which is usually up to a week before the scheduled meeting.
To reserve a spot, you will need to provide the Clerk the following information:
The agenda item you will be speaking on.
Your (or your organization’s) full name and contact information.
If you require a translator, or if you will be bringing your own.
Things to keep in mind:
Deputation sign-ups are first-come, first-served. The courtesy deadline is 4:30pm the night before the scheduled meeting, but you can still sign up in-person on the day of the meeting.
To keep a written record, it is best to email your request to the Clerk.
Ask the Clerk to provide your speaker number in their response.
3. Prepare your public deputation
A public deputation is your chance to express your opinions or experiences with the issue. You only have a limited time to present, so you need to use it wisely! When preparing your public deputation, ask yourself: am I making my point in a clear and understandable way?
A typical deputation follows this format:
A) Thank the Chair and the committee.
B) Introduce yourself and why you are speaking. If you are representing a group, explain briefly their focus and concerns.
C) Explain your concerns and how they affect you and the community. While it’s best to be as personal as possible, using examples, statistics, and other research can help your argument.
D) Thank the Chair, the committee, and Council and remind them that you will be observing their voting on this issue.
The time limit for your presentation is five minutes, however, this can be reduced to 2-3 minutes at the discretion of the committee. Following your presentation, committee members may ask you questions. Each member is limited to five minutes, including their question and your answer.
If this is your first time deputing, you may want to attend a meeting beforehand to observe how a meeting is run and to watch other people depute. You can also find some examples of previous public deputation online, such as: Deputations on proposed cuts to student nutrition programs (December 7, 2011).
Be organized!
It’s always best to be well prepared for a deputation. If this is your first deputation, staying organized will help calm your nerves and ensure you don’t miss any important points. Keep these tips in mind for staying organized:
Write down a few notes, or your whole speech – whatever makes you feel more comfortable!
Practice your deputation ahead of time. Ask your friends and family for feedback.
If you are using supporting material, have their sources readily available to cite. After your deputation, a City Councillor may ask you about this.
Make sure you can adjust your speech time. If you are reading from a written statement, having two versions (five minutes and two minutes) is helpful.
Check for any meeting changes (time, location, etc.) the night before.
Know your topic!
Your deputation will be much more effective if you are well informed about your issue. You are not expected to be an expert, but you should know enough to answer questions from committee members. Some things to keep in mind:
What research has there been on your issue?
Providing statistics and support material can strengthen your argument.
Highlight evidence from other jurisdictions or from already-implemented programs in the city that are comparable.
What is the larger community’s outlook on your issue?
Linking your views with the broader community can help bolster your argument.
Scan social media and local newspapers.
Look up any advocacy groups that address your issue. They may assist you by providing useful resources and advice.
Where do committee members stand on your issue?
Knowing how committee members stand can help you tailor your argument.
Look at previous committee meeting minutes, council reports, and voting patterns.
Let your City Councillor know ahead of time that you will be making a deputation.
Invite them to come to the meeting room to hear you.
Send a copy of your deputation to your City Councillor.
Even if your City Councillor does not sit on the committee that you are presenting to, it is still useful to let them know your views and priorities. They may even give you useful tips for your presentation!
4. Present your public deputation
The following tips and instructions will help ease your nerves on your big day.
Arriving at the committee meeting room:
Be as early as possible.
Familiarize yourself with the room: the committee Chair sits at the front and centre of the committee room, the committee Clerk usually sits to the left of the committee Chair, committee members sit around the table. When it is their turn, Deputants sit facing the committee Chair.
Get a copy of the deputation list, which shows the order of speakers and the issues they are deputing.
Confirm the time allotment for speeches. While the standard time for a deputation is five minutes, this may be reduced to 2-3 minutes.
Be patient: some agenda items can take several hours if they are also hearing deputations.
Making your deputation:
The committee will call your name up to three times when it is your turn to speak.
If you would like to provide supporting materials, give them to the Clerk for distribution.
Check if the microphone is on and adjust it as needed.
Thank the Chair and committee.
Introduce yourself and why you are speaking.
Speak evenly and clearly.
Smile, make eye contact, and try not to be nervous!
Be respectful, but don’t be afraid to challenge the committee if you are not being treated with respect or dignity.
At the end of your deputation, thank the Chair and committee again.
After your deputation:
Wait to see if committee members have any questions about your deputation.
If there are no questions, you are free to leave or can stay to hear the rest of the meeting.
Congratulate yourself on a job well done!
5. Follow up
A few weeks after the meeting, you will be sent a copy of the committee’s decision by mail.
Follow up with your City Councillor to see if they support your position and the committee’s decision.
Continue to watch for any new developments about your issue.